每日國際新聞⚙︎ 設定關鍵字
行銷 · Marketing Week · 11/18 15:03

B2B marketing needs to tackle its streetlight problem

B2B marketing needs to tackle its streetlight problem
重點摘要
It's easy to see why B2B marketers are drawn to spending where it is easiest to measure success - but that doesn't mean your marketing is effective. Source

There is an old story about a man searching for his keys under a streetlight.

You probably know it. Behavioural science has been dining out on it for years, and so has fellow columnist Johnny Corbett, in his new The Line In The Sand series.

Naturally, in this version, the man is Barry. I find him on his hands and knees beneath the light, patting the pavement with the quiet desperation of someone who has either lost his car keys or is trying to reconcile three different attribution dashboards.

“I’ve lost my keys,” he says. After a few minutes of looking, I ask the obvious question, “Are you sure you dropped them here?”

“No. Over there, by the car.”

“So why are we looking here?”

Barry points upwards. “Because this is where the light is.”

This is known as the Streetlight Effect: our tendency to search where it is easiest to look rather than where the answer is most likely to be. B2B media planning has developed a particularly expensive version of it.

Social is beautifully illuminated. Every impression counted. Every click recorded. Every job title reassuringly attached to a person who may, with luck, even remember seeing the thing. And B2B marketers love it.

‘Embrace the change or get left behind’: Inside the rise of B2B influencersMarketing Week’s State of Brand in B2B research found that 80.8% invest in social for brand building — more than any other channel.

The awkward bit is that only 57.9% of CMOs rate it as effective. By contrast, more than three quarters rate PR and editorial as effective.

So we appear to be spending most heavily in one of the places we trust least. Not because B2B marketers are idiots but because measurement is seductive. Precision feels like evidence. A dashboard full of verified job titles gives everybody something comforting to point at when finance asks where the money went.

But knowing exactly who received an impression is not the same as knowing how much that impression was worth. That is the precision trap. We optimise for the part we can see most clearly, then quietly confuse visibility with effectiveness. And it comes with at a costs.

What precision costs B2B marketers

**1. Attention.** What is slightly bonkers is that attention still isn’t the default way we think about this. Media measurement began with an “opportunity to see”. The important word there is opportunity.

It is a perfectly reasonable description of a poster. Less impressive as the finishing line for modern advertising. Digital gave us “viewability”, largely because advertisers were being charged for ads no human had any realistic chance of seeing. A necessary improvement. But an extraordinarily modest one.

A display ad can qualify as viewable when just half its pixels appear on screen for one second. Half an advert. One second. Somehow, a technical minimum has been promoted into a measure of media quality.

Research cited by Lumen shows why that matters: a large proportion of technically viewable impressions are never actually noticed.

The better questions are obvious. Did anybody look? For how long? And what did that attention cost? A verified job title is not the same thing as a verified moment of attention.

**2. Trust.** B2B buyers are not merely choosing a supplier. They are attaching their own judgement to one.

Get it wrong and Barry cannot simply forward the consequences to the vendor and disappear for lunch. He still has to explain why he chose them. So familiarity matters. Reputation matters. Visible commitment matters.

There is power in a promise made in public because it has witnesses. It puts your reputation on the line. A private promise delivered with exquisite targeting to one individual carries a different signal when nobody else knows you made it.

It’s time to throw away the B2B playbook and embrace creatorsThat helps explain why environments differ in trust. The Credos Trust Tracker puts UK trust in TV advertising at 46%, OOH at 38%, magazines at 37% and newspapers at 35%. Social media sits at 27%.

Where the advertising appears is part of what the advertising says. A headline sponsorship at the biggest event in your sector says: we expect to be here for a while. A sponsored post says: we successfully located your job title.

Both can be useful. They are not saying the same thing.

**3. Reach.** Then there are all the people that precision is exceptionally good at excluding. LinkedIn’s B2B Institute and Ehrenberg-Bass popularised the 95-5 rule, at any one time, most potential B2B buyers are not currently in market.

Brand building therefore has a job beyond finding whoever happens to be shopping this Tuesday. Precision is excellent at finding the person you have already decided matters.

It is rather less good at finding the person who matters next year. Or their new boss. Or the finance director who appears two weeks before the decision and asks why nobody considered Competitor B.

The supposed “wastage” in broader media is not always waste. Some of it is tomorrow’s pipeline. Or even a hidden buyer.

Before anyone gets cross: this isn’t an argument against targeting.

Direct mail is about as targeted as media gets, and in B2B it can work brilliantly. A well-made object lands on somebody’s desk, earns physical attention and visibly costs something to produce and send.

…Gasp! proved the point rather literally with SkillSoft by sending ten customers a box containing what appeared to be rubbish.

Inside each clear Perspex case was a personalised letter, screwed up and suspended like something rescued from the bin. The idea was to dramatise wasted investment, create a little constructive tension and earn considerably more attention than another polite renewal email ever would.

It was extremely targeted. It was also physical, conspicuous and impossible to scroll past.

Nine of the ten companies responded. Six renewed, including one four-year deal signed early. Approximately £10,000 of spend helped secure £503,285 in renewals: more than 5,000% ROI.

The problem is not precision. Precision at the expense of attention, trust and effect is. The mistake is assuming that because we can identify exactly who received something, we have proved the communication mattered.

What breaking the mould looks like

Some B2B brands have already stepped away from the brightest bit of pavement.

Heat pump brand Qvantum needed to reach a small, specialist audience: the engineers specifying heating systems for new homes.

The obvious answer was to find them digitally and follow them around until either they bought a heat pump or applied for witness protection. Instead, the campaign appeared on the London Underground and roadside sites, catching engineers on the way to work.

“Our audience is small and specialist, and the easy option was to just chase them around LinkedIn. Going onto the Underground and the roadside felt bolder, but that was the point. We wanted engineers to see a brand that’s here to stay, not one more ad in their feed,” says Sarah Atkinson, marketing director at Qvantum.

The targeting did not disappear. It just stopped meaning “must be delivered inside a feed”. That is the broader principle. Choose the channel for what it does to the audience, not for how neatly it behaves in the post-campaign PowerPoint.

The numbers are closer than you think

The standard defence of targeted media is straightforward. Broader media wastes money because most people exposed will never buy. And if the only calculation is CPM, that can look compelling. Cheap impressions look wonderfully efficient when every impression is treated as an identical unit.

Human attention is less cooperative. Attention measurement gives planners another lens: instead of only asking what a thousand impressions cost, ask what a thousand attentive seconds cost.

Lumen’s published benchmarks, using illustrative media costs, put a 30-second TV spot at £1.70 per 1,000 attentive seconds and conventional OOH at £1.79. Facebook feed: £8.34. Standard display: £13.02. That is not evidence that television and posters always beat social. Media costs change. Audiences differ. Formats differ. Creative matters enormously.

B2B brands report higher effectiveness than B2C brands, DMA data findsIt is evidence that the apparently cheapest impression can become rather expensive once we insist somebody actually notices it.

The same Lumen benchmarks show why. Lower-CPM social and display formats generated substantially fewer attentive seconds than higher-attention media in the comparison set. So, the planning approach is not to crown a channel winner on CPM alone. Model audience composition, attention cost and attentive reach separately.

Who are we reaching? What chance do we have of them actually noticing? What are we paying for that attention? CPM can stay in the spreadsheet. It just shouldn’t chair the meeting.

A better test

Next planning round, ask every channel three questions:

1. How much of the buying committee will it reach, beyond the target list? 2. How much attention will those people actually give it? 3. What does it say about us that we’re there?

Social will still earn its place on plenty of plans. It just should not earn it automatically.

Too many B2B media plans begin with LinkedIn and work outwards, asking what else can be afforded once the feed has been fed. That is not media neutrality. It is a platform habit wearing the clothes of strategy.

And it creates a peculiar situation in which marketers can tell you exactly how many people received an impression while remaining much less certain whether anybody noticed, trusted or remembered it.

Marketing Week’s own B2B research suggests marketers already feel this tension: the channel attracting the greatest brand-building investment is not the one they rate most highly for effectiveness.

That ought to make us curious. The answer is not to abandon social, targeting or measurement. It is to stop confusing what is easiest to measure with what is most effective to buy.

If the job is to build a brand and a business, start with the buyer, the buying group and the effect you need to create. Then choose the media. Not the other way round.

The streetlight is useful. But only if that is where you dropped the keys.

⚠️ 這則新聞翻譯失敗,內容保留英文原文。

← 回到 2026-11-19 新聞列表